Category Archives: A New Ambivalence

Anthropologists debate whether beer or bread spawned civilization: a metaphor for humanity’s struggle for survival versus the quest for enlightenment.

Helpful Hallucinations on Beer, Bronchitis, and Cookies

The premise of this entry is twofold and quite simple. But first a hallucination.

I lay my head down, close my eyes, and while I’m no A+ student of The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test, I swear I’m swirling right into psychedelia. The little scientist who perches on that knot in one shoulder tells me I’m not exactly a control subject here. A lowered tolerance these days may have turned my ten ounces of Haystack Wheat into a bender. That sweet hometown Left Hand beer is spiced tonight with antibiotics, one last day of prednisone, and an albuterol inhaler— all of which are coursing through my system at this very moment. And a coughing fit moments ago over the sink made me see stars. But I’m convinced my little trip is of a different source.

As soon as my eyelids shut, a tiny visual wonderland plays before my sight. This is not the lava lamp lightshow I can sometimes achieve when I squint my closed eyes and follow the blood flow. All around me are fascinating colors, textures, and three-dimensional spaces through which I can choose to drift. I can even alter the scenery with the merest effort of curiosity and interest, a sort of conscious dreaming. The panorama pulses to a rhythmic thumping and the landscapes gently rise and fall below me. The sensation is both real and surreal: it is Beth’s heartbeat and breathing beneath my head.

A brief mental journey back out of this trip and into the past: do you remember hearing the story of the two girls in Durango— I think of them as the cookie phantoms— who left an anonymous plate of homemade cookies at a neighbor’s door, then knocked and hid? The anxious woman panicked, imagining some menace, and went to the hospital the next day fearing a heart attack. She successfully sued the girls in small claims court (check out the blog linked here, by the way: it reveals some interesting details not often shared on the case).

The third point of the Boy Scout Law says “a scout is helpful.” [Background: I’m pondering each of the 12 points, one a month, throughout this year’s centennial of American scouting.] This topic seemed at first too obvious— the classic picture of a boy helping an old lady across the street— and thus unappealing to me. But it’s hardly my style to take the obvious tack. I choose tonight, instead, a New Ambivalence.

Helpfulness can certainly backfire, especially when it is about helping oneself. If the cookie phantoms had primarily been indulging their own desire to do a good thing— regardless of whether it was appreciated— then they were missing the point of helping others. I will come to their aid yet, but must return right now to the trippy la-la land encircling my head.

Her heart-thump is just below my ear. I move my cheek down off her ribcage, thinking “the human head weighs eight pounds.” (Thank you Ray: you complete me. Along with Rod Tidwell’s rants, you were one of the two bright spots in Jerry Maguire. I’m not anti-chickflick, but I am a boy after all.) From my lower position over Beth’s belly, her pulse is still audible. And then I hear dinner gurgling its way down. That sound and sensation, right there against my own skin, returns me smiling to my happy hallucination.

DrugsIt’s been a tough five weeks of constant illness, long (but satisfying) working hours, and tension on the home front. In stress and ailment I tend to take care of “number one,” but in the past few days I recognize how hard Beth, too, has made special efforts for my health. Today I took the time— and it was not painful or difficult— to return the favor. And here, head-on-belly, in the giddy throes of a real-life hallucination called love, we are helping ourselves to the simple rewards of genuine helpfulness.

Maguire: Did you know that Troy Aikman, in only six years, has passed for 16,303 yards?

Ray: D’you know that bees and dogs can smell fear?

Maguire: Did you know that the career record for hits is 4,256 by Pete Rose who is NOT in the Hall of Fame?

Ray: D’you know that my next door neighbor has three rabbits?

Maguire: I… I can’t compete with that!Jerry Maguire 1996

The two-fold premise of this entry I promised at the beginning? Listen to other people’s hearts. And bring them cookies.

Thanks for reading. Cheers,
Greg

Photo by the Beer Phantom

Beer vs. Bread? But I Like Both!

Once upon a time we were nomadic beings with opposable digits, roaming the earth for food. We thumbed our noses at lesser mammals but they couldn’t thumb us back, so we became lonely. Next we sought something higher to thumb our noses at … and thus began civilization.

The dilemma of “beer or bread” is an ongoing debate that makes anthropologists more interesting than our normal chatter. This much we know, or think we do: mankind started settling into sedentary life around 9,000 B.C., give or take a few millennia. Hunting and gathering wasn’t a bad way to accumulate the calories of sustenance people needed to survive, but settling down provided access to crops, specifically grains, which offered two important new perks: bread and beer.

The bread camp argues that the first rudimentary loaves provided a reliable food source to last through those brutal winters, dramatically helping survival rates. This, they say, was the reason people settled down and started raising crops and livestock.

The beer camp says life was nasty, brutish, and short both before and after the dawn of civilization. Some of them contend it is still equally nasty and brutish, but now extended, thanks to medical advances. Beer, they say, provided a respite from the struggles of survival. It offered lonely humans, kings atop their own egocentrically designed animal kingdom, a glimpse of something higher and more mysterious. In other words, they finally got good and drunk and had a little fun.

Of course I’m oversimplifying here, or perhaps utterly vandalizing, a long-respected academic debate. This blog— and this introductory entry— is really more a characterization of the tug-of-war within my own head: sustenance vs. transcendence, work vs. play, vegetables vs. dessert.

I’m not the first to set aside my 3-D eyeballs in order to try out this 2-dimensional outlook. The late Claude Lévi-Strauss, an anthropologist who never wore jeans, is arguably the first thinker to turn his social science into a binary art. Most of his work might seem too baffling for a casual read, for instance a CNN tribute a few days ago said his approach “makes difficult concepts more complicated, but also softens them and makes them more comprehensible.” If that makes any sense to you then you’re ready for his most influential work, The Raw and the Cooked.

Levi-Strauss contributed a fascinating arsenal of tools that we anthropologists now use to dissect and overanalyze the human condition. In essence he argued that there was wisdom to be gained by breaking down our culture (and really all reality) into its constituent dichotomies. Food is either raw or cooked. You are either grounded or airborne. People are either male or female.

Ask your neighborhood hermaphrodite: there are certainly limitations if you think this was meant to sum up all of life in one algorithm. It wasn’t. It’s merely a pair of 2-D glasses you can wear into this 3-D film we call life. Beer versus Bread is a pair of such spectacles. It may share with you a little glimpse of my world as a 15-year marketing professional, 5-year freelance writer, and 37-year human-in-progress.

Early, humble beginnings: a bowl of mush in a mud hut
A perfect sphere, perfectly clear, in a mess of gray gloppy porridge
The first bubble in the world’s first beer
In eons to come, from Cairo to Compton
Souring livers, fertilizing epiphany
One tiny bubble: potion or poison?
—by me, 2002

Claude Lévi-Strauss, the father of modern anthropology, died on October 30, 2009 at 100 years old. As a small tribute, here are his own words from 1955:

The world began without the human race and will certainly end without it.
—Claude Lévi-Strauss

I’ll drink to that. Thanks for reading. Cheers,
Greg

Photo by SteamboatDigs (a.k.a. yours truly)